Real Estate Values and Property Tax Valuation in Shelby County, Illinois

Shelby County has 3,794 properties with a cumulative value of $436.1M, representing 0.06% of all real estate value in Illinois. Property taxes in Shelby County totaled $9.3M, with the average homeowner paying $2,458 in property taxes compared to the state average of $5,405. The average property tax rate in Shelby County is 2.14%, lower than the state average of 2.47%. Property taxes are based on the assessed value of the property, which is determined by the local assessor.

In Illinois, property taxes are based on the value of the property as of January 1st. Property owners have the option to appeal their property taxes between June and December, or within 30 days of when the notices are published. Property tax bills are issued on February 1st and July 1st, with the first installment due on June 1st in Cook County. This first installment is estimated at 55% of the prior year's tax bill, with taxes paid in arrears.

Important Dates
Property Valuation Date:January 1st
Property Tax Appeal Deadline:June - December or 30 days after notices are published
Property Tax Bills Issued:February 1st and July 1st
Real Property Tax Bill Due (1st of #):June, Two installments but due dates may vary by county March 1st, Cook County - 1st half installment, estimated at 55% of prior year tax bill with taxes paid in arrears.
Real Property Tax Bill Due (2nd of #):September, Two installments but due dates may vary by county August 1, Cook County - 2nd half installment - TARGETED but may be delayed - due 30 days after being issued. Reconciled installment using the BOR certified AV, actual local tax rate, and final state equalization factor, less the estimated 1st installment with taxes paid in arrears
Available Exemptions
SeniorAvailable
DisabledAvailable
HomesteadAvailable
VeteranAvailable
Solar/WindAvailable
CharitableAvailable

Don't Miss Your Property Tax Appeal Deadline

Ownwell will automatically evaluate all new property tax assessments, identify if you should appeal, then handle the end to end property tax appeals process. With our Savings-or-Free guarantee, only pay 25% of your property tax bill savings after you save!

Real Estate Statistics in Shelby County

Total Real Estate Value
$436.1M
Total Real Property Taxes
$9.3M
Average Property Tax Rate
2.14%
# of Real Properties
3.8K

Residential Property Taxes by Cities in Shelby County

Shelby County has an average property tax rate of 2.14%, which is slightly lower than the national average of 2.18%. This rate is applied to the assessed value of a property to calculate the total property taxes due. Property taxes collected in Shelby County in 2023 are estimated to be around $9.3 million.

Property tax rates vary across the cities in Shelby County. Tower Hill has the highest effective property tax rate at 2.23%, while Windsor has the lowest effective property tax rate at 1.92%. The average property tax bill in Shelby County is estimated to be around $2,458. Property taxes are an important source of revenue for local governments in Shelby County, and understanding the differences in property tax rates across cities can help homeowners make informed decisions when buying or selling a home.

Tax Assessment Value

The following table shows the 10th, 25th, 50th, 75th, and 90th percentile of property assessment value in each city in Shelby County. The tax assessment value may differ from the potential sale value, and is used to calculate the property tax for each piece of real estate.

City10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian75th Percentile90th Percentile
Shelbyville$19,889$48,780$99,423$161,306$209,609
Tower Hill$18,062$43,668$86,004$129,543$183,451
Windsor$22,685$61,990$113,847$178,953$238,687

Property Tax Bill

This table shows the percentiles of actual property tax paid on residential properties for each city in Shelby County.

City10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian75th Percentile90th Percentile
Shelbyville$419$1,028$1,967$3,266$4,389
Tower Hill$360$720$1,819$2,995$4,544
Windsor$497$1,000$2,090$3,430$5,163

Effective Property Tax Rate

The effective property tax rate is calculated by dividing the property tax bill by the assessed value. For the percentiles below, the calculation is performed using the percentiles for property tax bill and assessed value above. Therefore, each consecutive percentile doesn't necessarily show a larger value.

City10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian75th Percentile90th Percentile
Shelbyville 2.11% 2.11% 1.98% 2.02% 2.09%
Tower Hill 1.99% 1.65% 2.12% 2.31% 2.48%
Windsor 2.19% 1.61% 1.84% 1.92% 2.16%

Reduce your property tax bill with Ownwell!

Ownwell saves property owner's $1,149 a year on their property taxes. Sign up in 5 minutes to start saving today! With our Savings-or-Free guarantee, only pay 25% of your property tax bill savings after you save!

Real Estate Values in Shelby County

The median home price in Shelby County, Illinois has seen an increase of 22.80% from October 2022 to October 2023, rising from $125.0K to $153.5K. This indicates a strong trend of rising home prices in the area. However, the home inventory in Shelby County has decreased slightly from 43 in October 2022 to 42 in October 2023. This suggests that the demand for homes in the area is outpacing the supply, which is likely contributing to the increase in home prices.

Median Sale Value
$153.5K
Total Active Listings
42
Annual percent change in median sale price
22.80%

Average Home Value in Shelby County, Illinois

Last updated: November 2023

Percent Change in Total Home Sales in Shelby County

Last updated: November 2023

Percent Change in New Home Listings in Shelby County

Last updated: November 2023

Reduce your property tax bill with Ownwell

Ownwell will evaluate your property tax assessment, build a case, and file an appeal. With our Savings-or-Free guarantee, only pay 25% of your property tax bill savings!

Mortgage Rates in Shelby County

Mortgages in Shelby County are a major factor in the local economy. The total outstanding loan amount across home mortgages in Shelby County is $9.6M, with 66 outstanding loans. This represents a significant portion of the total home value in the county. The median mortgage rate in Shelby County varies across cities, with Tower Hill having the highest rate at 4.25%, and Windsor having the lowest rate at 3.84%. This variation in rates across counties can be beneficial for those looking to purchase a home in Shelby County, as it allows them to shop around for the best rate.

Overall, mortgages in Shelby County are a major factor in the local economy, and the variation in rates across cities can be beneficial for those looking to purchase a home in the county. With a total outstanding loan amount of $9.6M and 66 outstanding loans, Shelby County is a great place to find a home and secure a mortgage.

# of Outstanding Loans
66
Total Outstanding Loan Amount
$9.6M
Properties with Loans
1.74%

Outstanding Mortgages

The table below shows the percentile distribution of outstanding loans on residential properties in Shelby County by city.

City10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian75th Percentile90th Percentile
Shelbyville$55,420$86,633$123,889$147,583$203,921
Tower Hill$135,630$144,661$180,358$215,410$244,635
Windsor$93,285$133,164$199,738$256,352$288,448

Mortgage Rates

The following table shows the 10th, 25th, 50th, 75th, and 90th percentile of mortgage rates in cities across Shelby County.

City10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian75th Percentile90th Percentile
Shelbyville 2.84% 3.60% 3.93% 4.25% 4.54%
Tower Hill 2.87% 3.85% 4.25% 4.80% 5.25%
Windsor 3.10% 3.44% 3.84% 4.45% 4.75%

Housing Expenses in Shelby County, Illinois

Reduce your property tax bill with Ownwell

Ownwell will evaluate your property tax assessment, build a case, and file an appeal. With our Savings-or-Free guarantee, only pay 25% of your property tax bill savings!

With Ownwell's property tax monitoring service ensures you'll never overpay on property taxes again.

How Ownwell works?

  1. Enter your property address and get an instant estimate of your potential tax savings based on local market data and our historical tax savings in your area.
  2. Sign up online and authorize Ownwell to fight your tax bill in less than 5 minutes.
  3. Sit back and let us get to work. Ownwell handles everything start to finish with no up-front costs. It’s all backed by our industry-leading Savings-or-Free Guarantee.
  4. When we save you money our fee is just 25% of your savings. If you don't save, you don't pay. We will continue to monitor your property taxes every year to ensure that you never overpay or have to worry about your property taxes again.

Reduce your property tax bill with Ownwell

Enter your property address and get an initial estimate of your potential tax savings based on local market data and our historical tax savings in your area. We never share or sell your information.

Frequently asked questions

We currently operate in Texas, California, Washington, Georgia, Florida and Illinois.
We use a private national data provider that cross-references with county recorder's offices to verify ownership. If in the event our system is unable to verify the property, our team will take further steps to investigate ownership and reach out to the customer for confirmation.
Our success rate varies across geographies; however, in any given year, we typically win more than 70% of our cases, saving clients an average of $1,457 on their property taxes.
Yes, in the market areas we serve, we have a dedicated Property Tax Consultant that is physically present in the market they are servicing. The specialist assigned to your property has the necessary geographical competence to provide exemplary service!
The average property tax rate in Shelby County is 2.14%.
The following exemptions and discounts are available in Shelby County: Charitable, Disabled, Homestead and Senior

Explore Property Taxes in Your City